The Best Candy Choices for Halloween: 8 Sweet Picks from $0.25 to $2.99
Whether you're prepping for a flood of trick-or-treaters or curating the perfect candy bowl at the office, choosing the right Halloween candy matters. With so many options on the shelves—from bite-sized classics to artisanal chocolate creations—it can be hard to know where to start. That’s why we’ve ranked the best candy choices for Halloween, starting from affordable fan favorites all the way to premium picks that stand out. If you're in Minneapolis or the Twin Cities and looking to sweeten the season, this guide will help you build a candy mix that’s both budget-conscious and crowd-approved.
Table of Contents
1 8 Best Halloween Candies (Ranked)
2 Tips for Building the Perfect Halloween Mix
3 Final Thoughts: Trick-or-Treat with Intention
🎃 8 Best Halloween Candies (Ranked from $0.25 to $2.99)
1. Tootsie Rolls (~$0.25 each)
A Halloween classic that never goes out of style. Tootsie Rolls are chewy, chocolatey, and budget-friendly—perfect for handing out by the handful. Their long shelf life and iconic wrapper make them a staple in every trick-or-treat bag across Minneapolis neighborhoods.
2. Dum Dums (~$0.25 each)
Affordable, colorful, and endlessly fun. These mini lollipops are a hit with kids because of their wide range of flavors (Mystery Flavor, anyone?). They’re also allergen-friendly, making them a safe and inclusive choice for large groups.
3. Smarties (~$0.30 per roll)
Sweet, slightly tangy, and perfectly portioned. Smarties are great for younger kids, classrooms, or candy bowls where you want something light and nostalgic. Their pastel colors and crunchy texture make them a fun, mess-free option.
4. Laffy Taffy (~$0.35 each)
These stretchy, fruity candies are a favorite for their bold flavors and built-in laughs (yes, every wrapper comes with a joke). Laffy Taffy adds a playful twist to any candy mix, and is especially loved by older kids and teens.
5. Kit Kat Miniatures (~$0.50 each)
Snap, share, smile. Kit Kat Minis are a timeless favorite with their crispy wafer and milk chocolate combo. They’re small enough for trick-or-treat bags but satisfying enough to leave a lasting impression. Plus, they’re always among the first candies to disappear at any party.
6. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups – Fun Size (~$0.75 each)
A Halloween MVP. Reese’s Cups strike the perfect balance between salty and sweet, and their peanut butter center is pure comfort. They're one of the most requested candies by trick-or-treaters—and they make a great reward for adults raiding the candy bowl later.
7. Sweet Chocolat Oreo Cookie – $1.99
Want to give out something that feels special? This handcrafted Oreo Cookie from Sweet Chocolat is dipped in rich artisan chocolate and beautifully decorated for the season. At just $1.99, it’s the perfect mid-range indulgence to stand out from the basic candy bag. Ideal for Halloween party favors or for trick-or-treaters who really earned it.
👉 Grab it here while it lasts!
8. Premium Artisan Truffles or Chocolate Barks – $2.49+
If you're looking to wow your guests or put together elevated Halloween gift bags, finish strong with a handcrafted chocolate truffle or bark. Locally made options (like Sweet Chocolat’s barks) offer rich flavors, beautiful textures, and an unforgettable experience. Not your average Halloween candy—but that’s exactly the point.
🎃 Tips for Building the Perfect Halloween Mix
Not all candy bowls are created equal. Whether you’re preparing for trick-or-treaters, coworkers, or party guests, here are a few tips to help you create a Halloween candy mix that’s both exciting and practical:
Mix Price Points: Blend budget-friendly candies with a few standout pieces like Oreo Cookies or artisan chocolates to surprise and delight.
Think Texture & Flavor: Combine chewy, crunchy, fruity, and chocolatey options so there’s something for everyone.
Include Allergen-Friendly Options: Choose at least one or two candies that are nut-free or gluten-free so no one feels left out.
Presentation Matters: Use a themed bowl or small treat bags with spooky labels—it turns your candy station into part of the decor.
Reward the Extra Effort: Keep premium candies (like the Sweet Chocolat Oreo Cookie) aside for standout costumes or close friends.
🍫 Final Thoughts: Trick-or-Treat with Intention
Halloween is about more than candy—it’s about fun, community, and tiny moments of magic. Whether you stick to the classics or add a touch of artisan sweetness, the best candy choices for Halloween are the ones that make people smile.
And if you’re looking to take your treats to the next level this year, check out our handcrafted chocolates and seasonal sweets—because a little chocolate joy never goes unnoticed.